
Page 1 of 1
-
- phillh
- Member Since: 15 Sep 2025
- Location: Herts
- Posts: 8
Do I need a new battery?
Good evening,
I have owned my 2017 D5 3.0 HSE since October 25 and really love it.
My only query is if I leave the car for a week or more, I get the 'Low Battery - Start Engine' come up on the dash. Is this a common thing or should I renew the battery?
I tend to user the car only for longer runs as I understand they don't like being used on short journeys in town as it can clog up the emissions systems. Otherwise I would use it a lot more.
Many thanks
PhillH -
- Mole HD
- Member Since: 19 Nov 2024
- Location: Orkney Islands
- Posts: 884

Hi Phill.
I get the same if I don't use the car for a few days. Usually a run around the island for an hour sorts it out for a few days at least...we only have 25 miles of single track roads around the island so unfortunately most of my journeys are short stop/start. I usually stick a bottle of Wynn's DPF cleaning fluid in the tank when I top up with diesel, it helps stop the ash build up in the DPF a bit.
Besides that, short journeys or not...turn the auto/stop start off during those trips through the town, your engine and battery will thank you for it...just as the car will with being used instead of being parked up.
Once every few weeks, I head over on the ferry to Mainland and blast the car around the decent A roads over there for a while to give it a decent run out at higher revs until I get the local ferry back home.
Like yours, mine is a 2017 HSE and I suspect the battery is now 9 years old and a bit tired...I'll be looking to replace it at some point with a decent Bosch 95AH one, the OE battery is 80AH so the Bosch (or similar AGM brand) will be better suited to the limitations of living on a small rock in the north sea.
I usually buy from here
.
Last edited by Mole HD on 22nd Apr 2026 9:35 am. Edited 5 times in total -
- phillh
- Member Since: 15 Sep 2025
- Location: Herts
- Posts: 8
Thanks Mole,
Will keep an eye on it. Thanks for the tip about Tanya batteries btw. -
- Wolfpack
- Member Since: 25 May 2019
- Location: Norfolk, UK
- Posts: 574

My 2017 still did that even after replacing the battery.
I have a habit of leaving the car unlocked at home (in the rear of our property). Do that a couple of nights and the battery will be asking to be recharged.
The funny thing is…it’s stopped doing it so much recently.
Since having software updates reloaded at main dealer I have noticed several changes to the vehicle. One is that the auto stop/start seems to kick in more regularly…even after shortish journeys. It’s as if the battery is getting a better charge now.
Just my observation.
. -
- 747_JK
- Member Since: 26 Jun 2018
- Location: England
- Posts: 497

On my fourth battery (three replacements) in my MY23.5. I find they are bloomin' useless, but all mine have been replaced under LR Assist, so it's at their cost, not mine, But still!
My BlackVue dashcam probably doesn't help, but it was a pro install and the settings are set to switch the thing off a the most sensitive of battery levels, so as not to risk anything. That said, after 10 days on the drive last summer whilst away on hols, the car was effectively totally dead.
I just kind of live with it... the other day, when cleaning/loading the car prior to returning from hols in Scotland, with the doors & boot open for a good couple of hours, I ended up just switching the ignition on for the last 35/40 mins, just to ensure no "low battery" warnings when wanting to leave swiftly to catch the ferry next morning...
MY23.5 D5 3.0 MHEV Metropolitan Edition – Santorini Black – Ebony Windsor Leather – 21” Style 5025 gloss black wheels – 21” full size spare tyre – Black roof rails – Black side mouldings - Williams Ceramic Coat. [Gone: D5 HSE @ 50,795miles: (now LH68 BYW)] -
- phillh
- Member Since: 15 Sep 2025
- Location: Herts
- Posts: 8
Thanks for your replies. I will monitor it and fit a little voltage meter in my accessory port to make sure the alternator is charging correctly. -
- DieselRanger
- Member Since: 12 Oct 2017
- Location: God's Country, Colorado
- Posts: 811

Re: Do I need a new battery?
phillh wrote:
Good evening,
I have owned my 2017 D5 3.0 HSE since October 25 and really love it.
My only query is if I leave the car for a week or more, I get the 'Low Battery - Start Engine' come up on the dash. Is this a common thing or should I renew the battery?
I tend to user the car only for longer runs as I understand they don't like being used on short journeys in town as it can clog up the emissions systems. Otherwise I would use it a lot more.
Many thanks
PhillH
I only just this spring replaced my factory battery on my 2017 HSE Td6. I was astonished that it lasted this long. Its degradation was fairly graceful, however, in the last few weeks of its life I had to jump it, until one day it simply could not be resuscitated. I did occasionally get the Low Battery - Start Engine notification in the months before that.
I replaced the battery myself (in a ski lodge parking lot, where it ultimately died) - you'll need a few tools but hopefully nothing you don't have at home. The retaining bracket was a bit of a bear to get off as the battery cables were kind of packed in there and very stiff in the cold.
Now I keep it on a battery tender at home if it's going to sit for a while, even though the battery is brand new and a highly rated premium unit. -
- Penuwchian
- Member Since: 01 Sep 2025
- Location: Wales
- Posts: 23
Changed the battery on my 2017 2.0lt yesterday. Only 25k miles on it but the same battery from new.
Mole's Tanya batteries came good- great price and next day delivery -
- Mole HD
- Member Since: 19 Nov 2024
- Location: Orkney Islands
- Posts: 884


-
- Narpy
- Member Since: 30 Apr 2025
- Location: Stockport
- Posts: 170

As a footnote to this thread, I had suspected my battery as being a bit goosed since I bought the D5 just over 12 months ago. I’d become used to its driving habits but after changing the battery it’s like driving a different car. Gone is the constant warning that the spare tyre is low on pressure ( it never has been ) and the car drives much smoother with the jerkiness I’d become accustomed to, also gone.
Whilst changing the battery I also took the time to unplug the awful stop/start lead and that too has transformed the driving experience. Furthermore, the powered tailgate now operates as it should and I’ve discovered it has a sensor ( which now works ) to prevent the tailgate closing if there’s an obstacle. That definitely didn’t work pre-battery change.
So, to sum up, if you’re suffering some minor but annoying car related issues, consider changing your vehicles main battery especially if it’s a few years old and still has the original installed. Better still, consider fitting a Bluetooth battery indicator so you can monitor the battery from the comfort of your armchair.
Bluetooth Monitor Linky
Buy Your Battery Here Linky
How To Change Your D5 Battery Linky
This has been a Narpy “I never expected that” Awareness Post
-
- Wolfpack
- Member Since: 25 May 2019
- Location: Norfolk, UK
- Posts: 574

That’s interesting re the spare warning light. I’ve had that annoyance for the last year or more. Tried rotating the tyre to no avail. I assumed it was the TPMS in the tyre that had “failed” and was considering getting it changed at the next service.
Don’t understand how changing the battery (which presumably only offers the potential for higher voltage/current) should impact the tyre warning or the jerkiness in driving? However my wife says my driving is jerky (think that’s the word she used lol) so maybe I should do a drop test on the one I’ve got which is probably 3/4 years old before going any further with the tyre sensor.
I suppose I assumed that IF it was purely the battery then I might have seen the tyre warning light not appearing immediately after a long drive, when the battery was now sufficiently charged for the infamous stop/start to kick in?
So much I don’t know about this car! -
- Narpy
- Member Since: 30 Apr 2025
- Location: Stockport
- Posts: 170

I honestly can’t explain why the spare tyre suddenly started to report the correct pressure. It’s possible that changing the battery caused some sort of hard reset so that’s something that may be worthwhile doing before splashing out on a replacement battery.
I too, thought the tyre pressure sensor in the spare wheel was paggered and had considered getting it sorted under warranty before it ran out, I guess I don’t need to bother now.
The difference between pre and post battery swap is astounding however and I cannot recommend it highly enough if you even remotely suspect your battery is defective. -
- Wolfpack
- Member Since: 25 May 2019
- Location: Norfolk, UK
- Posts: 574

The strange thing is that I too experienced a similar step change in behaviour / performance when I had the free security update. I doubt it was the security update itself that effected the change but the required update of the cars software, which had been neglected for the last 3 years.
It felt like a new car. Calmer and yet more responsive. A refreshing greater pleasure to drive.
It was suggested by more knowledgeable people than I, that it could have been the “learned driver settings” being wiped back to default. In other words, all my bad driving habits (according to the wife) that the car had adopted and used as my preferred way to drive were gone.
Whatever it was, something seemed to be reset to a better state. Since that honeymoon period I must have been a bad influence on it again as the car is back to being less calm.
It would be interesting to see if that state of Nirvana could be returned, by swopping batteries.
Thx for sharing. -
- Narpy
- Member Since: 30 Apr 2025
- Location: Stockport
- Posts: 170

No problem.
I’ve gotta be honest here, I hadn’t noticed the slightly jerky ride until it was cured and had become accustomed to driving with an amber TPMS light on the dash. I can only conclude that a long slow change becomes accepted as normal until it suddenly disappears and you find yourself looking/waiting for it to occur, as for the amber light, that was obvious immediately.
Oddly, I often kept the old battery topped up via the CTek and even at 100% charge, the TPMS light was still illuminated and the slightly jerky ride was evident so perhaps there is something in the hard reset thing.
I hope that makes sense, -
- Mole HD
- Member Since: 19 Nov 2024
- Location: Orkney Islands
- Posts: 884

Most car batteries will need replacing if they're 5 or more years old...like everything, they have an effective operating life regardless of the actual mileage on the vehicle. 3-5 years is about average across most brands...and most AGM (Absorbent Glass Mat) batteries that are compatible with single battery auto stop/start operation will come with that length of time reflected in a guarantee or warranty.
When chosing a replacement battery, the 2 important numbers to look at, besides the physical dimensions and guarantee period, are the Capacity (the higher the better) and Cold Cranking Amperage (CCA). Once again, the higher the better. The Bosch battery I have fitted now is 95AH (capacity) and with an 850A CCA (cold cranking amperage). I'm not trying to preach...many folks will know all this stuff through experience but some, who might never have attempted any sort of DIY car maintenance may not.
Anyways, don't go buying or fitting 2nd hand batteries to save a few pennies...it's false economy, always buy new from a reputable supplier.
Back on topic...I'd mirror the same sentiments after replacing my ancient 9 year old 80AH factory fitted battery with a new Bosch 95AH (from Tayna Batteries). The Bling Barge seems less...fussy and pernickety if you know what I mean, not to mention no more 'Battery low, please start engine' if I leave it sitting idle for a few days.
Some of the improvements could well be attributed to resetting the BMS after fitting the new battery though...it works similar to a soft reset of everything that demands a bit of voltage/amperage from the battery... it's a bit like restarting your phone when it starts playing up.
If you don't reset the BMS after a battery change...it'll gradually drift back to throwing up some particular issues since the BMS regulates voltage/amperage distribution. If it's not been reset to reflect having a fresh battery fitted, it'll still be utilising the values it had with the tired, old battery. Replacing the battery will work fine without resetting the BMS of course...but the recuperation or improvements probably won't last as long.
The BMS also regulates charging rates from the alternator and prevents over or under charging of the battery during normal operation. It also monitors battery temperature to improve longevity of the battery. My honest advice? If you can't DIY resetting the BMS...pop into an Indy garage and have them do it.
It's a bit like re-gassing the HVAC, which really needs doing every 2 to 5 years. The cost of a DIY kit is the same price as going to an indy garage for a drive in regas service...swings and roundabouts. If you have the kit...fine. If not, the drive in service costs the same as buying a basic regas kit online...around £100.
All that said...the biggest favour you can do for your battery...not to mention the engine, starter motor and everything else on a pre facelift, non hybrid D5... is to turn the damned auto stop/start off...either by pressing the button every time you start the car, pulling the 2 pin plug off the battery terminal (like Narpy) or by editing the CCF with an IID tool to enable last user memory mode. Like EGR's, DPF's and all the mechanically destructive emission control systems forced onto modern diesels...they're an absolute curse.
On a recent trip from Aberdeen back oop north to Scrabster for the Orkney ferry, it really set my teeth on edge listening to every second diesel engined car painfully rattling back into life half a dozen times just moving up the odd slow queue for roadworks or dual carriageway roundabouts...Don't attribute auto stop/start with any sort of fuel economy either...that's not what it does or why it's there.
As to resetting the BMS...most generic OBD2 diagnostic tools will offer a BMS reset option (and other service or maintenance related functions on a D5)...we're not talking of the expensive toys like IID tools or CR Max's, some of the far cheaper, budget efforts readily available from Halfrauds or online will do perfectly well for basic service interval resets and BMS or DPF resets on a pre facelift D5....just check it covers basic Jaguar/Land Rover service functionality for 2016/2017 onward.
Page 1 of 1
- Forum Permissions
- You cannot create new threads in this forum
You cannot reply to threads in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
- Tools
- Previous Thread · Next Thread
DISCO5.CO.UK is independent and not affiliated to Jaguar Land Rover.
